Tesla's overexcited fans should cool down a little

Elon Musk’s electric car company has shown resilience during the pandemic but its share price jump this week has been over the top.
New electric automobiles, manufactured by Tesla Inc., sit on the dockside after being imported to the Port of Southampton in Southampton, UK. (File photo used for representational purpose) (Bloomberg)
New electric automobiles, manufactured by Tesla Inc., sit on the dockside after being imported to the Port of Southampton in Southampton, UK. (File photo used for representational purpose)

(The following is a Bloomberg opinion piece written by Chris Bryant)

Back when Tesla Inc. delivered 95,000 cars to customers during the spring quarter of 2019, the stock price was languishing at about $235 and Elon Musk’s electric car company was valued at “only" $40 billion. Fast forward a year and the shares are now priced at more than $1,200. With a market capitalization of $224 billion, Tesla has surpassed Toyota Motor Corp. as the world’s most valuable automaker.

Also check these Vehicles

Find more Cars
Tesla Model S (HT Auto photo)
UPCOMING
75 kWh 200 396 km
₹70 Lakhs - 1 Cr
View Details
Tesla Model 3 (HT Auto photo)
UPCOMING
82kWh 225 kmph 555 km
₹ 70 - 90 Lakhs
View Details
Hyundai Kona Electric 2024 (HT Auto photo)
UPCOMING
64.8 kWh 172 Kmph 418 Km
₹ 25 Lakhs
View Details
Hyundai Kona Electric (HT Auto photo)
39.2 kWh 167 kmph 452 km
₹ 23.79 - 23.98 Lakhs
Compare
View Offers
Odysse Electric Odysse Electric Hawk (HT Auto photo)
2.96 kWh 45 Kmph 170 Km
₹ 73,999 - 98,500
Compare
View Offers
Battre Electric Mobility Battre Electric Loev (HT Auto photo)
3.1 kWh 65 Kmph 60 km
₹59,900
Compare

Yet in the second quarter of 2020, Tesla delivered 91,000 vehicles — about 5% fewer than the same period last year. That’s pretty underwhelming for a company whose fans view it as a fast-growing technology company in the mold of Amazon.com Inc., rather than a sluggishmetal-bashing carmaker. So how is the massive recent jump in its market value justified?

In fairness, it shows resilience to sellthis many cars when the company’s main California plant was shut by the pandemic for much of the spring period. Doubtless, Tesla’s new Shanghai plant picked up the production slack, which suggests the expense and effort of getting thatChina factory up and running was worth it. The launch of Tesla’s new Model Y crossover vehicle will have helped. Ford Motor Co. and General Motors Co. both saw their U.S. deliveries decline by a third in the same quarter.

Nevertheless, Tesla’s stock marketacolytes pushed the shares up another 8% on Thursday, adding $16.5 billion to the market value. Such exuberance ishard to understand. Musk’s company sold 7,650 more vehicles than analysts expected during the second quarter, and the stock price jump equates to about $2 million of added shareholder value for each of those additional sales. This seems a little excessivegiven that a Tesla Model 3 sells for less than $40,000, and the profit marginon those cars is pretty slim.

The shareholder reaction makes even less sense when you consider that Tesla investorsaren’t really meant tobuying the stock because of the company’s current sales, which are less than 4% of Volkswagen AG’s. Rather, the investment case is a long-term one: that it will come to occupy a dominant position in clean transport and energy in the years ahead. That explains why the shares trade at 320 times its analyst-estimated earnings this year. Viewed through this lens, Tesla’s ability to shifta few thousand extra cars in recent weeks shouldn’t matterso much for the valuation.

Investors’ tendency to overreact to Tesla newsmade more sense when its survival was open to doubt. A year ago it was laying off workers, U.S. sales were slowing and its retail strategy was confused. Senior staff kept heading for the exit. The company was burning through cash and ran pretty low on financial fuel. It had just $2.2 billion of cash in March 2019, compared with more than $8 billion now.

But subsequent evidence that Tesla can sell cars for more than it costs to produce them has transformed the mood — and with it Tesla’s stock price.

File photo of Tesla CEO Elon Musk. (REUTERS)
File photo of Tesla CEO Elon Musk. (REUTERS)

Instead of “killing" off Tesla, the tepid electric offerings of established carmakers such as Audiand Mercedes have only underscored the quality of their rival’s battery and powertrain technology (the same can’t be said of Tesla’s build quality). Volkswagen’s software problems with its forthcoming ID.3 electric vehicle suggest catching Tesla won’t be straightforward, even with the Germans’ vast resources.

Tesla’s stratospheric valuation appears to have become self-reinforcing. Should it require more money to fund its roughly $9 billion of capital expenditureover the next three years, it can raise it from shareholders without worrying about diluting them too much.

Similarly, holders of more than $4 billion of convertible bonds that Tesla issued to fund its expansion should be happy to convert them into stock, rather than demand cash repayment, taking some of the pressure off the company and its balance sheet.

Still, Tesla’s valuation remains impossible to justify byany standard metrics. Analysts’ average price target is more than 40% below the current level. Even Musk has suggested that the share price, which has almost trebled since the start of 2020, is too high — although, as with his taunting of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and his comments about “fascist" lockdowns, it’s usually better to tune out what Musk says and focus on his actions instead.

The skeptics might have more faith in Tesla’s new position asthe leader of the automaker pack when Musk stops his provocations and his shareholders stop getting giddy over modest good news.

First Published Date: 04 Jul 2020, 08:23 AM IST
NEXT ARTICLE BEGINS

Please provide your details to get Personalized Offers on

Choose city
+91 | Choose city
Choose city
Choose city

Want to get the best price for your existing car?

Powered by: Spinny Logo
By clicking "View Offers" you Agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy

Dear Name

Please verify your mobile number.

+91 | Choose city
Couldn't verify the OTP.
It's either expired or it's incorrect.